
Kelly and I recently watched V for Vendetta, a film based on the graphic novel by Alan Moore and David Loyd published in the 1980s. I was talking with somebody about this movie the other day and they said that they totally hated the movie. I can see and respect how one might dislike this movie...but the same aspects of the movie that caused them to dislike it are exactly why I would recommend it!
The "hero" of the film is a terrorist, and the film wrestles with this and is ambiguous as to whether or not the terrorist is actually "good" or not. Most people like movies that have very clear delineations between the "bad guys," and the "good guys." V for Vendetta does not.
There is a point in the film where V (Hugo Weaving) has just revealed to Evey (Natalie Portman) that he killed a very corrupt political figure. She is upset at him for doing so, but he quips something to the effect, "You didn't seem to mind when I killed a man who was attacking you!"
I won't ruin the story for you, because I think you should see it! But there's another point where V says to Evey, attempting to justify his actions, "What they did to me was monstrous!" and she responds, "And they created a monster!" I believe terrorism is not justifiable, and we are always responsible for our own actions, however, terrorists are usually created by their circumstances. One man's terrorist is another man's freedom fighter! In the musical "Wicked" there's this line in a song,
"A man's called a traitor
or liberator.
A rich man's a thief
or philanthropist.
Is one a crusader,
or ruthless invader.
It's all in which label,
is able to persist.
There are precious few at ease,
with moral ambiguities,
So we act as though they don't exist!"
What is our response when a corrupt, violent, Authoritarian Government (like in V for Vendetta) is in place? Do we sit back and accept the lies that they tell us, or do we respond? What is our response when innocents are maliciously trampled upon and abused? Do we sit back knowing that we haven't been harmed, or do we respond? What about when we know that someone is going to turn us over to our death? Do we just let it happen, or do we respond? As a follower of Christ, I must stand up for truth, and the poor and disenfranchised, and I must respond, AND I must respond in love, which, by definition, "does no harm." I do not condone the actions of the "hero" of the film, but neither do I support the government which he opposes. SO, we must ask ourselves, how in the world do we respond?!
There are two other movies that I think approach this topic well. The Boondock Saints, and Munich. V for Vendetta is violent, but it's more like Matrix violence but with a little more blood. Both of the other movies are violent as well, however Munich is by far the most violent film I've ever seen. I cannot actually recommend anyone seeing it, because I seriously suffered traumatically from the images in that film. However, V for Vendetta is brilliant, Orwelian, and timely, and I think it's a great place to begin such a conversation.
As far as responding to injustices in our world, our quote of this month says something about that, "Non-violence is the answer of our time's crucial political and moral questions. The need for man to overcome oppression and violence without resorting to violence and oppression." --Dr. Martin Luther King, Jr. For more on that, though not written by Dr. King, check out a fantastic book that deserves, but won't herein, get it's own post, Choosing Against War: A Christian View, which is definitely a book that has been formational to my understanding of God's love and how we as Christians should be reflecting and extending that to a hurting world.